This thread is waay to long to get through so will add some thoughts after a few searches.
You made that comment back in 2004 !
Have you changed your your mind since wrt to 1 vs 1 ?
On the program 'Deadliest Warrior', they had a simulation of Samurai vs Spartan
The Spartan came out tops due to the big shield. This is for 1 against 1 but results are quite close.
Is it fair to say if the Spartan could do it so could the Knight ?
This goes for open battle, which is completely different. So many situations possible if armies faced each other on the battlefield, the knights seemingly would have the advantage.
In the episode where a Spartan takes on the Samurai, its the Spartan that wins and the biggest advantage is due to the shield. But its a close fight. Out of a 1000, 527 vs 473.
In the show with the Viking vs the Samurai, the Samurai wins but it was again very close. Out of a 1000 simulations, 522 vs 478.
I think these results are not enough to have any conclusion, on any given day it could go either way.
Originally posted by Officer of Engineers
View Post
Have you changed your your mind since wrt to 1 vs 1 ?
On the program 'Deadliest Warrior', they had a simulation of Samurai vs Spartan
The Spartan came out tops due to the big shield. This is for 1 against 1 but results are quite close.
Is it fair to say if the Spartan could do it so could the Knight ?
Originally posted by Officer of Engineers
View Post
Originally posted by Blademaster
View Post
In the show with the Viking vs the Samurai, the Samurai wins but it was again very close. Out of a 1000 simulations, 522 vs 478.
I think these results are not enough to have any conclusion, on any given day it could go either way.
Comment