+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 39
  1. #1
    Banished Great Lencucha's Avatar
    Join Date
    27-02-06
    Posts
    44

    Worst decision in WW2

    In 1941, Canada sent a not fully equiped and not compleatly trained battalion to Hong Kong. The British asked Canada to put soldiers in Hong Kong and Canada agreed even though their was no way to hold the island. Of the 1975 Canadian troops sent their 290 were killed in battle and 300 died in Japanese POW camps.

    I say they just should have gave the island up, instead of having their soldiers die in a battle they knew they couldn't win.

  2. #2
    HKHolic Senior Contributor leib10's Avatar
    Join Date
    17-02-05
    Location
    Lubbock, TX
    Posts
    3,436

    Operation Barbarossa. Germany lost the war because of the invasion of Russia. There was just no way that they could win. Operation Autumn Mist was also a pretty stupid idea.

    Also, some Canadian decisions during the Normandy campaign were pretty shitty as well. There were many instances when the Canadians could've dealt a mortal blow to the Germans, but because they did not advance aggressively enough they gave the Germans more time to set up defences. According to Kurt Meyer, commander of 12. SS Division "Hitlerjugend", several times the Canadians could've taken Caen and other strategic points with ease if they had advanced faster and didn't use their tanks in the infantry support role.
    "The right man in the wrong place can make all the difference in the world. So wake up, Mr. Freeman. Wake up and smell the ashes." G-Man

  3. #3
    Senior Contributor gunnut's Avatar
    Join Date
    27-01-06
    Location
    DPRK, Demokratik People's Republik of Kalifornia
    Posts
    17,739

    Japan's sneak attack on Pearl Harbor.

  4. #4
    A Self Important Senior Contributor troung's Avatar
    Join Date
    03-08-03
    Posts
    5,628

    Entering Poland...

  5. #5
    Military Professional
    Staff Emeritus
    Scotch taster

    Join Date
    06-08-03
    Posts
    22,793

    There was one thing that I've learned while in service. Hindsight is always 20/20. You have to see these decisions within context, even stupid context. We/they should have known better BUT they did not.

    Hong Kong is a prime example. British military thinking at the time was that wars would be actions on the roads. Control the roads and you control the action. It simply did not occur to anyone that whole corps can travel off road that fast.

    One cannot view Juno Beach without understanding the Dieppe experience.

    And of course, there was Montgomery who really is a legend in his own mind. The man, in his mind, never lost a battle.
    Chimo

  6. #6
    Title Classified Senior Contributor
    Join Date
    23-11-04
    Location
    Mississippi
    Posts
    1,144

    Quote Originally Posted by leibstandarte10
    Also, some Canadian decisions during the Normandy campaign were pretty shitty as well. There were many instances when the Canadians could've dealt a mortal blow to the Germans, but because they did not advance aggressively enough they gave the Germans more time to set up defences. According to Kurt Meyer, commander of 12. SS Division "Hitlerjugend", several times the Canadians could've taken Caen and other strategic points with ease if they had advanced faster and didn't use their tanks in the infantry support role .
    (emphasis mine)

    A flaw tht plagued all Allied armies until the very end of the war. You simply can't expect commanders to completely throw out their doctrine and fight in ways they haven't trained or even thought about on a whim.
    "We always have been, we are, and I hope that we always shall be, detested in France."
    -Sir Arthur Wellesley

  7. #7
    Bandaid Military Professional
    Join Date
    04-10-04
    Location
    India
    Posts
    5,977
    Quote Originally Posted by Officer of Engineers
    And of course, there was Montgomery who really is a legend in his own mind. The man, in his mind, never lost a battle.
    Very true sir. They say he was a man of patience, or was it that he did'nt know what to do?...Op Market Garden is one of his classical blunders - he ended up loosing the British 1st Airbone Division, 2000 odd men survived out of 12,000.

    Cheers!...on the rocks!!

  8. #8
    Military Professional
    Staff Emeritus
    Scotch taster

    Join Date
    06-08-03
    Posts
    22,793

    Accroding to his biography, he didn't think Market-Garden was a disaster. Never mind the fact he did not held ground, he pulverized the Germans. The man would not accept he has been defeated.
    Chimo

  9. #9
    New Member
    Join Date
    03-08-03
    Posts
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by Officer of Engineers
    Accroding to his biography, he didn't think Market-Garden was a disaster. Never mind the fact he did not held ground, he pulverized the Germans. The man would not accept he has been defeated.
    Market garden was certainly the biggest W. Allied blunder of the war IMO.

  10. #10
    Military Professional
    Staff Emeritus
    Scotch taster

    Join Date
    06-08-03
    Posts
    22,793

    I think Italy surpassed that. It was the only time where the Allies abandonned their strategic objectives.
    Chimo

  11. #11
    New Member
    Join Date
    03-08-03
    Posts
    0
    Italy was stupid, but at least we took it. Market Garden was stupid and a failure, lol.

    Letting Norway fall without any real fight was really stupid too.

  12. #12
    Military Professional
    Staff Emeritus
    Scotch taster

    Join Date
    06-08-03
    Posts
    22,793

    We couldn't win the war through Italy and had to shift our orientation both physically and psychologically to another AO. So did the Germans but they had an easier time with interior LOCs.

    MG is to me a big blunder in more ways than one. It made the following Schelt action much harder. MG allowed the Germans time to fortify the Schelt. MG, however, made the Battle of the Schelt that much more important, the 1st port in Allied hands.

    In essence, we told the Germans where to get ready and gave them the time to get ready.

    Which all begs the question, how the hell did Monty think MG was a success? His biography only states that he pulverized the German formations in front of him.
    Chimo

  13. #13
    Actus Reus Senior Contributor sparten's Avatar
    Join Date
    10-04-04
    Location
    You would like to know would'nt you?
    Posts
    1,695

    Did'nt he say it was a 90% success?
    "Any relations in a social order will endure if there is infused into them some of that spirit of human sympathy, which qualifies life for immortality." ~ George William Russell

  14. #14
    Military Professional
    Staff Emeritus
    Scotch taster

    Join Date
    06-08-03
    Posts
    22,793

    Quote Originally Posted by sparten
    Did'nt he say it was a 90% success?
    He was the only one.
    Chimo

  15. #15
    Actus Reus Senior Contributor sparten's Avatar
    Join Date
    10-04-04
    Location
    You would like to know would'nt you?
    Posts
    1,695

    Okay back to WW2 blunders, the Arakhan offensives in Burma.
    Made Market Garden seem smart.

    And the defence of Singapore, Churchill kept sending people over, even when it was clear that the defence was hopeless. Sentenced 130,000 men to Japanese hospitality.
    "Any relations in a social order will endure if there is infused into them some of that spirit of human sympathy, which qualifies life for immortality." ~ George William Russell

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

     

Similar Threads

  1. MPAs slam jirga’s decision to legitimise honour killing
    By Ray in forum International Politics
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 6th May 2006, 17:07
  2. Replies: 69
    Last Post: 18th August 2005, 21:47
  3. Gangs rule world's worst city
    By Jay in forum International Economy
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 22nd September 2004, 20:14

Share this thread with friends:

Share this thread with friends:

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts