Flipside of the COIN

**Shek** · 04-11-2007, 19:42 PM

http://usacac.army.mil/CAC/csi/OP21_...%20version.pdf

Quote:

In view of the adoption of the term “The Long War” by the United States Joint Chiefs of Staff to describe US operations against terrorism and state sponsored terrorism, we have decided to change the title of our long running series of studies on irregular warfare – from the Global War on Terrorism Occasional Papers to the Long War Occasional Papers.

This CSI Occasional Paper is the first in the renamed series. The purpose of the series, however, remains unchanged. That is, to provide short historical monographs on topics of doctrinal and operational relevance to the US Army and military professionals for an Army at war.

We are therefore pleased to offer Long War OP #21: Flipside of the COIN: Israel’s Lebanese Incursion Between 1982-2000, by Captain Daniel Helmer. Captain Helmer’s study, written while studying at Oxford University, addresses the Israeli view of the threat posed by various armed factions in southern Lebanon over an 18-year period. This was a period during which Israeli used air strikes, ground invasions, and border operations to contain or defeat the military threat to its national security.

Among the key points the author makes in this study is the inability of Israel to use military force to secure a lasting political end state in Lebanon that was favorable to its security needs, despite some stunning battlefield victories.

Helmer also notes that both Palestinian and Hezbollah leaders recognized they could not militarily defeat Israeli military forces, despite occasional tactical success, but that this was not their political objective. Rather, they needed only to survive and to maintain their forces in the field to achieve their long-term objectives. Weaker powers have often employed this strategy against their stronger opponents. He also notes the steady dwindling of political and public support in Israel for the occupation of Lebanon and the role this played in Israel’s decision to withdraw from Lebanon in 2000.

As the recent 2006 Israeli attack into Lebanon against Hezbollah terrorists has shown, however, these strategic challenges and dilemmas remain unsolved. In the first decade of the 21st century, it is clear that these dilemmas are not unique to Israel and that the United States might draw some insights relevant to our own situation.

Kartajan · 04-12-2007, 13:41 PM

If we are completely honest with ourselves, we have to agree that Israel has half-pulled itself and has been half pushed into a very unique position in terms of counter-insurgency. In that position it both enjoys military advantages and suffers political disadvantages.

The impossibility of finding diplomatic solution with Lebanon or political settlement with a friendly Palestinian faction is the price they pay for the greater variety of military options available to Israeli policymakers.

Thats their bargain. Others make other bargains, and get other goods in return. Some satisfactory, some not.

WECIV · 04-13-2007, 13:59 PM

I truly feel we are part of Isreal's problem. We have influeced them with our method of warfare. Technology over common-sense.

Shek, good read, thanks for the post.

W

Ray · 04-13-2007, 15:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kartajan

If we are completely honest with ourselves, we have to agree that Israel has half-pulled itself and has been half pushed into a very unique position in terms of counter-insurgency. In that position it both enjoys military advantages and suffers political disadvantages.

The impossibility of finding diplomatic solution with Lebanon or political settlement with a friendly Palestinian faction is the price they pay for the greater variety of military options available to Israeli policymakers.

Thats their bargain. Others make other bargains, and get other goods in return. Some satisfactory, some not.

http://www.worldaffairsboard.com/int...-problems.html

The posts are worth check!

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
New Dollar Coin	THL	World Affairs Board Pub	23	02-13-2007 19:42 PM
New Rules for New Enemies	Shek	The Field Mess	6	11-11-2006 19:01 PM
Organizing Infantry	Anoop C	The Field Mess	42	09-06-2006 00:54 AM
In Iraq, the U.S. fights an enemy it hardly knows.	Ray	The War in Iraq	15	05-28-2006 15:04 PM

04-12-2007, 13:41 PM	#2 (permalink)
Kartajan Regular Join Date: 03-14-07 Posts: 46	If we are completely honest with ourselves, we have to agree that Israel has half-pulled itself and has been half pushed into a very unique position in terms of counter-insurgency. In that position it both enjoys military advantages and suffers political disadvantages. The impossibility of finding diplomatic solution with Lebanon or political settlement with a friendly Palestinian faction is the price they pay for the greater variety of military options available to Israeli policymakers. Thats their bargain. Others make other bargains, and get other goods in return. Some satisfactory, some not.

04-13-2007, 13:59 PM	#3 (permalink)
WECIV Regular Join Date: 11-13-06 Posts: 88 Country:	I truly feel we are part of Isreal's problem. We have influeced them with our method of warfare. Technology over common-sense. Shek, good read, thanks for the post. W

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)