View Poll Results: Was Grant's idea for the assault at Cold Harbor:

Voters
5. You may not vote on this poll
  • A good idea poorly executed

    3 60.00%
  • A bad idea doomed to failure

    2 40.00%
Results 1 to 9 of 9

Thread: Grant at Cold Harbor

  1. #1
    Staff Emeritus
    Military Professional
    Defense Professional Shek's Avatar
    Join Date
    23 Feb 05
    Location
    Krblachistan
    Posts
    11,636

    Grant at Cold Harbor

    I've got all four of the Gordon Rhea books on the Overland Campaign (he has yet to publish his fifth and final book) and was thumbing through the Cold Harbor book last night. Some very fascinating analysis and I think he frames it beautifully within the context of the campaign and the conditions. He thinks the assault on June 3 was a logical choice for Grant, and I think his arguments were compelling, especially in light of the casualty numbers he derives, 3500 for the AOP and 500 for the ANV, which cuts the ratio in half from the most oft cited figures.

    Was the assault a good idea poorly executed or a bad idea from the start?
    "So little pains do the vulgar take in the investigation of truth, accepting readily the first story that comes to hand." Thucydides 1.20.3

  2. #2
    Global Moderator
    Military Professional
    Defense Professional
    Albany Rifles's Avatar
    Join Date
    27 Apr 07
    Location
    Prince George, VA
    Posts
    8,288
    And I'll have an expansion on this later...I know its a shock that I would have an opinion on this!
    “We had been hopelessly labouring to plough waste lands; to make nationality grow in a place full of the certainty of God… Among the tribes our creed could be only like the desert grass – a beautiful swift seeming of spring; which, after a day’s heat, fell dusty.”
    ― T.E. Lawrence, Seven Pillars of Wisdom: A Triumph

  3. #3
    Staff Emeritus
    Military Professional
    Defense Professional Shek's Avatar
    Join Date
    23 Feb 05
    Location
    Krblachistan
    Posts
    11,636
    Quote Originally Posted by Albany Rifles View Post
    And I'll have an expansion on this later...I know its a shock that I would have an opinion on this!
    Did you get stuck in the mud reconnoitering the assault line or did Vista crash again )?
    "So little pains do the vulgar take in the investigation of truth, accepting readily the first story that comes to hand." Thucydides 1.20.3

  4. #4
    Global Moderator
    Military Professional
    Defense Professional
    Albany Rifles's Avatar
    Join Date
    27 Apr 07
    Location
    Prince George, VA
    Posts
    8,288
    Quote Originally Posted by Shek View Post
    Did you get stuck in the mud reconnoitering the assault line or did Vista crash again )?
    I am looking around for Baldy Smith and I can't find him!

    I got caught up trying to redo the architecture for future systems requirmeents in the BCTs...damn work!

    But I did get my operational art homework done! Go check it out.

    I'll try to ellucidate after Scouts tonight...
    “We had been hopelessly labouring to plough waste lands; to make nationality grow in a place full of the certainty of God… Among the tribes our creed could be only like the desert grass – a beautiful swift seeming of spring; which, after a day’s heat, fell dusty.”
    ― T.E. Lawrence, Seven Pillars of Wisdom: A Triumph

  5. #5
    Staff Emeritus
    Military Professional
    Defense Professional Shek's Avatar
    Join Date
    23 Feb 05
    Location
    Krblachistan
    Posts
    11,636
    Having just finished the 4th book of Rhea's 5-volume set, I'd have to agree with his assessment of the attack at Cold Harbor. The risk vs. reward equation was skewed heavily in favor of the attack, and while the assault on 3 June ended up as the 5th bloodiest day of fighting for the Union army during the Overland Campaign, had they succeeded in exploiting the breakthrough of the salient in Hancock's zone of attack, then they would have been able to turn the flank of the ANV while the ANV had its back essentially pinned to a river.

    In the end, I see a strategically correct decision that was executed poorly because of Grant and Meade being too disengaged from the corps commanders. I'd like to read up more on Meade and specifically on the Grant-Meade relationship, as I don't know whether to pin the rose on Grant for not having removed Meade (thus burdening Grant with tactical control of the AoP, detracting from his ability to keep abreast of all Union activities and shape them) or on Meade for being sour grapes and not adapting to Grant being in charge.

    Ironically, had Grant attacked 18 hours earlier, instead of being a Confederate (Pyrrhic) victory, it could have been the end of the ANV and Grant may have delivered Richmond to President Lincoln in time for the GOP Convention a few days later.
    "So little pains do the vulgar take in the investigation of truth, accepting readily the first story that comes to hand." Thucydides 1.20.3

  6. #6
    Staff Emeritus
    Military Professional
    Defense Professional Shek's Avatar
    Join Date
    23 Feb 05
    Location
    Krblachistan
    Posts
    11,636
    Having traveled the ground a few times since the original post, I still agree with the decision to make the assault. Ironically, the state of Confederate prisoners from North Anna gave Grant the read that ANV morale was low, this was the last chance to get at it north of the James River, and the clock towards the expiration of the three year enlistments was inching ever closer for many units.
    "So little pains do the vulgar take in the investigation of truth, accepting readily the first story that comes to hand." Thucydides 1.20.3

  7. #7
    Global Moderator
    Military Professional
    Defense Professional
    Albany Rifles's Avatar
    Join Date
    27 Apr 07
    Location
    Prince George, VA
    Posts
    8,288
    Shek,

    You are hitting all of the high points I believe
    “We had been hopelessly labouring to plough waste lands; to make nationality grow in a place full of the certainty of God… Among the tribes our creed could be only like the desert grass – a beautiful swift seeming of spring; which, after a day’s heat, fell dusty.”
    ― T.E. Lawrence, Seven Pillars of Wisdom: A Triumph

  8. #8
    Staff Emeritus
    Military Professional
    Defense Professional Shek's Avatar
    Join Date
    23 Feb 05
    Location
    Krblachistan
    Posts
    11,636
    We are upon the 150th of Cold Harbor. Today's assault would penetrate Confederate lines and motivate Grant that all it would take was one more hard push and they would crack. Luckily for the Confederates, PGT Beauregard finally relented and released Hoke's Division from the Richmond garrison on 31 May, and they would fall in on the line where Wright had penetrated the Confederate earthworks on 1 June.
    "So little pains do the vulgar take in the investigation of truth, accepting readily the first story that comes to hand." Thucydides 1.20.3

  9. #9
    Global Moderator
    Military Professional
    Defense Professional
    Albany Rifles's Avatar
    Join Date
    27 Apr 07
    Location
    Prince George, VA
    Posts
    8,288
    This was a campaign that was continuous Confederate "just in time" reinforcements or Federal mishaps.

    Imagine if the Federals along the Brock Road knew about the unfinished railroad line, Warren gets up and supports Upton as well as Mott, the Federal staff work was better at Spotsylvania, Hunter takes Lynchburg and keeps Breckenridge in the Valley, Sheridan is able to pull a corps of infantry into the fight on 31 May.

    But agree, Grant needed to attack. Just wish it had been on 2 June rather 3 June.
    “We had been hopelessly labouring to plough waste lands; to make nationality grow in a place full of the certainty of God… Among the tribes our creed could be only like the desert grass – a beautiful swift seeming of spring; which, after a day’s heat, fell dusty.”
    ― T.E. Lawrence, Seven Pillars of Wisdom: A Triumph

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. A New Cold War?
    By captchasep in forum The Middle East and North Africa
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 03 Aug 07,, 22:18
  2. Replies: 93
    Last Post: 08 Jun 07,, 19:42
  3. has america lost its luck?
    By astralis in forum American Politics & Economy
    Replies: 71
    Last Post: 15 Nov 06,, 13:44
  4. Trek-Like 'Cold Plasmas' Shield, Cloak
    By Jay in forum Science & Technology
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 03 Oct 05,, 04:46
  5. Surprise Attack At Pearl Harbor - Right Or Wrong?
    By TopHatter in forum The World Wars
    Replies: 62
    Last Post: 23 Apr 05,, 02:21

Share this thread with friends:

Share this thread with friends:

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •