2008 Election | The Pub | The Field Mess | The Staff College | Bookmark WAB


Go Back   World Affairs Board > Military Forums > Naval Forces
Register FAQ WAB RSS Feed Forum GuidelinesMembers List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Greetings, and welcome to the World Affairs Board!

The World Affairs Board is one of the premier forums for the discussion of the pressing geopolitical issues of our time. Topics include foreign & defense policy, international security, military developments, weapons proliferation, terrorism, international strategic affairs, and politics. Our membership includes many from military, defense industry, and government backgrounds with expert knowledge on a wide range of topics. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so why not register a World Affairs Board account and join our community today?
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 09-19-2005, 10:24 AM   #16 (permalink)
Sameer
Banished
Senior Contributor
 
Join Date: 07-12-05
Posts: 2,541
The air version of Brahmos is lighter, this is btw mentioned in the article.

Only in theory can the Barak 2, Aster 30 etc intercept a Mach 2+ missile, this is mentioned in their brochure but they admit that it has never been tested against a supersonic missile.

Remember the big cry about the CHinese having the Sunburn missile in the late nineties and how no US carrier battlegroup could intercept it

You cant say the missile cannot be intercepted, but its an extremely dangerous missile and extremely advanced in terms of RAM propulsion, stealth features etc.

People have to understand that the Russians could not make a missile with a range greater than 300kms due to MTCR with India, the Brahmos was thus created so India could get the knowhow and now India by itself will increae the range of the missile in the Brahmos 2 phase.
Sameer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 10:29 AM   #17 (permalink)
indianguy4u
Real Madrid CF
Senior Contributor
 
indianguy4u's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-07-05
Location: Mumbai
Posts: 3,213
Country:
Hey sameer can DRDO increase the range to somewhere 1500-2000 km. That could be killer range. This version (brahmos) equiped subs would be a hot combo .
__________________
Hala Madrid!!
indianguy4u is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 10:29 AM   #18 (permalink)
Sameer
Banished
Senior Contributor
 
Join Date: 07-12-05
Posts: 2,541
Quote:
Originally Posted by JBodnar39
I dug a bit more on the net to get specifics on the Brahmos and from what I'm seeing it is a good missle, but certainly not revolutionary like it is being made out to be. It is indeed very very fast at Mach 3+, but so were other much older missles like the SSN22, SSN19, and AS-6. What I see is a design that can do what the AS-6/SSN-19 can do in relation to speed, but a smaller version at about the third the weight/range/and warhead size as the SSN19.

I'm sure that it has improved targeting over those older missles, but to me it simply seems like a modernized and smaller version of those missles. The warhead size is a bit bigger than something like Harpoon (660lbs v 488lbs for Harpoon) and its highspeed and longer range certainly give it an advantage over Harpoon in a bluewater engagement, but compard to Harpoon it is HUGE. The ship launched version is about 24' long and weighs 6600lbs compared to a shiplaunched Harpoon at 15' and about 1400 pounds. This is going to limit the number of missles that can be fitted on a surface ship dramatically. The Delhi's carry 16 SSN25's - if I'm not mistaken - and each of those is about 12 feet long, weighs 1400lbs and has a diameter of 42cm. The Brahomos is twice as long, almost twice as wide (at 67cm) and 4 and 1/2 times as heavy. As a result you would be able to fit - at the most - 8 and probably only 4 Brahomos on a Delhi in comparision to 16 SSN25's.

The Brahomos is too long and wide to be launched from any SSN that I am aware of. I saw a photo of one mounted under an SU-30. At 5500 pounds in an air lauched version the SU-30 can carry one - max. I guess - theoretically - you could mount one under a MiG-29K but with the new Indian carrier's ski-jump the MiG29K could probably barely take off with one (if at all) and the aircraft's range would be severly limited. So they question is, do you want a missle that is faster and longer ranged at the cost of being able to mount as half as many on your ships and a fourth as many on your aircraft?

Comments?

No

The Brahmos is being fitted on all 5year old ships and all new ships that come out of the docks. 1000 Brahmoses will be produced in the next 8-10 years from thearticle and readings from AFM.

The Scorpenes that the IN is getting cannot carry the Brahmos and will have the new Exocet series.

The Amur will be capable of it.

I doubt that the Kilos can, the carry the Klub.

The MiG-29K carrying the Brahmos?

The Russians say so, I have my doubts for the same reasons you mention, let us wait and see.

Each Brahmos costs around 3 million dollars, India will not seek to intergrate it with every single plane and ship, it does not need to, it is intergrating it with the army and air force and navy, enough.

Rememebr Pakistan for eg is right next door, you dont need a ship to launch the Brahmos.
Sameer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 10:31 AM   #19 (permalink)
indianguy4u
Real Madrid CF
Senior Contributor
 
indianguy4u's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-07-05
Location: Mumbai
Posts: 3,213
Country:
JBodnar39,
In our geopolitical region its 'THE WEAPON' to have. No one is arguing that its best & other empy boasts.

Last edited by indianguy4u : 09-19-2005 at 10:35 AM.
indianguy4u is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 10:34 AM   #20 (permalink)
indianguy4u
Real Madrid CF
Senior Contributor
 
indianguy4u's Avatar
 
Join Date: 03-07-05
Location: Mumbai
Posts: 3,213
Country:
Quote:
Originally Posted by sameer
Each Brahmos costs around 3 million dollars
If 10 crore is taken as value of each, it translates to 2 million US$.
indianguy4u is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 10:40 AM   #21 (permalink)
Sameer
Banished
Senior Contributor
 
Join Date: 07-12-05
Posts: 2,541
France is developing a new stealth supersonic ASMP-A 500 Km cruise missile , replacing the older ASMP
Sameer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 10:41 AM   #22 (permalink)
JBodnar39
Patron
 
Join Date: 08-08-05
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 222
Arm a Backfire with 4 or 6 of those - now that would be a potent combination
JBodnar39 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 10:42 AM   #23 (permalink)
Sameer
Banished
Senior Contributor
 
Join Date: 07-12-05
Posts: 2,541
The key reasons and features of the Brahmos are here

Evolution of war weaponary : Brahmos


1. 'Fire and Forget' missile
2. Long range up to 290 km
3. High supersonic speed, Mach 2.8
4. Variable flight trajectories
5. Low reaction time and simple to operate
6. Long range radar seeker with ECCM
7. High lethal due to supersonic speed and penetrating warhead
8. Universal for sea, sub-sea, shore based carrier and silo
9. Multi target capability


Tyuang the lo lo, i can confirm is 1/2*maximum range (289km) so higher than 120kms
Sameer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 10:46 AM   #24 (permalink)
Sameer
Banished
Senior Contributor
 
Join Date: 07-12-05
Posts: 2,541
Interview of Mr. A.S. Pillai - CEO BrahMos


Quote:

Russian president Putin visited the BrahMos design centre during his visit to India. Will it help the missile programme in any way?

Both the governments have appreciated the progress the joint venture has made in a short time and acknowledged it as a role model for any future joint ventures in strategic partnership. President Putin’s visit has given the go-ahead for the air-launched version of the missile to be developed and integrated with Su-30MKI. His visit to the BrahMos Weapon Design Centre and his meeting with the CEOs of the consortium of industries of BrahMos gave a major impetus to this programme, including the export component.


President Kalam gave some marketing tips to Team BrahMos. What’s the missile’s marketing mantra?

President Kalam said the missile should be marketed aggressively and exported in a year to take advantage of the already established product leadership. He also said competition will come within the next four to five years and hence production and marketing goals have to be fulfilled immediately. We are fully geared to fulfil his wish, as the joint venture has already established production centres, weapon complex design centre, international marketing group, training and documentation centre and participated in many international exhibitions to sensitise the market. BrahMos Aerospace is a total solutions company and our marketing mantra for BrahMos is: Many missions, one missile.

How is BrahMos different from other missiles?

In recent times, subsonic cruise missiles have been the most dominant weapon system in tactical warfare. The ability of BrahMos to fly at three times the speed of sound in a variety of trajectories, from multiple platforms against multiple targets with high precision, and to remain undetectable due to low radar cross section, makes it the most potent weapon system ever developed.

The Su-30MKI is said to be an ideal platform of BrahMos. Did you have to modify the missile to achieve this?

The present missile with certain modifications has been conceptualised to be an ideal weapon for Su-30MKI. The modifications ensure lesser weight of the missile for same performance, utilising the initial velocity of the aircraft. Design and development has just commenced. Interface details with the platform are being finalised involving partner institutions and the user.
Sameer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 10:54 AM   #25 (permalink)
Sameer
Banished
Senior Contributor
 
Join Date: 07-12-05
Posts: 2,541
From the article and AFM

I gathered

During the 8th test, the helicopter detected the target but the target was made to move away from the area and the missile was fired in the latter's "general direction". The Brahmos successfully searched for it, picked it up and punched a neat hole into it, intentionally above the waterline for study.

The overland Brahmos is mentioned with some "special image processing software" capability in the article. I guess he means TCM, some thing more than a simple radar altimeter. It may not have the Tomahawk's range but the land-based Brahmos is a decisive weapon. Just imagine a "Brahmos storm" !!
Sameer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 11:00 AM   #26 (permalink)
Sameer
Banished
Senior Contributor
 
Join Date: 07-12-05
Posts: 2,541
Here is the speculation

HI-LO RANGE= 290KMS
LOLO= 120KMS+

HI HI= ?


India is not a signatory of MTCR, Russia was, everone knows that India needed help so the Russians helped India but had to officially limit the range to 300kms, there is no doubt in any defence circle that Russia and India know how to make a longer range missile than that and the argument is that India needed to know how to propel the missile, russia has experience, India and Russia collaborated and India paid the Ruskies lots of dough and now India has a cruise missile and they are planning to increase the range to 700-800kms, so says Tom from ACIG.
Sameer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 11:42 AM   #27 (permalink)
Samudra
Senior Contributor
 
Samudra's Avatar
 
Join Date: 09-01-04
Location: North London
Posts: 4,437
Country:
The range obviously has been understated.

Yes , the Brahmos picked up a specific building like structure from a bunch of buildings and flattened it in one of the IA tests.Heard so on BR.I'm not a genuis, you know.

Quote:
The present missile with certain modifications has been conceptualised to be an ideal weapon for Su-30MKI.
The skeptics have now been answered.By the CEO of Brahmos himself.
There is a air launched Brahmos in the works.Yay.

Terror is thy name , death is in thy breath....

Last edited by Samudra : 09-19-2005 at 11:47 AM.
Samudra is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 13:21 PM   #28 (permalink)
Anon
New Member
 
Join Date: 08-03-03
Posts: 0
"
Only in theory can the Barak 2, Aster 30 etc intercept a Mach 2+ missile, this is mentioned in their brochure but they admit that it has never been tested against a supersonic missile."

Not in theory, but in mathematics.

I'd be stunned if Aster15/30 had any problems with Brahmos.

Aster is the state of the art in shipboard SAM design, and TREMENDOUSLY agile, with mindnumbing acceleration.
Anon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 13:23 PM   #29 (permalink)
Anon
New Member
 
Join Date: 08-03-03
Posts: 0
"Remember the big cry about the CHinese having the Sunburn missile in the late nineties and how no US carrier battlegroup could intercept it"

Yeah, it was a bunch of BS too.
Anon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2005, 14:44 PM   #30 (permalink)
Sameer
Banished
Senior Contributor
 
Join Date: 07-12-05
Posts: 2,541
Quote:
Originally Posted by M21Sniper
"
Only in theory can the Barak 2, Aster 30 etc intercept a Mach 2+ missile, this is mentioned in their brochure but they admit that it has never been tested against a supersonic missile."

Not in theory, but in mathematics.

I'd be stunned if Aster15/30 had any problems with Brahmos.

Aster is the state of the art in shipboard SAM design, and TREMENDOUSLY agile, with mindnumbing acceleration.


The Aster 15 cannot intercept a 2+ mach system, the Aster 30 can in theory, it has never been tested. Also the Brahmos does not fly in a straight line, it has low RCS and performes manouvers before hitting the target, you are forgetting that Russia worked with India in this project.

And the Sunburn had no anti missiles that could intercept it mate, I dont know where you got the BS notion from. the sea sparrow has been found lacking in intercepting mach 1.5+ missiles with a 15% success rate. (computer simulation)
The Brahmos is the latest in Russian knowhow.

Last edited by Sameer : 09-19-2005 at 15:11 PM.
Sameer is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply




Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Top Ten Chinese Military Modernization Developments oneman28 International Defense Topics 96 06-23-2008 01:49 AM
Littoral Combat Ship Analysis Dago Naval Forces 49 11-05-2007 18:12 PM
BrahMos cruise missile test-fired Ray South Asian Defense Topics 19 04-28-2007 20:00 PM
UK not part of anti-missile defence plans Ray The Western Alliance 53 03-12-2007 14:08 PM
Carrier killers (an article from JED online) lurker Naval Forces 172 12-28-2006 00:39 AM


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 15:07 PM.


Rochen is the business hosting sponsor of World Affairs Board and a provider of reseller web hosting services.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC8