ATO=a russian+chinese+indian NATO

1947 · 04-26-2008, 21:29 PM

would a Russian, Chinese and Indian organization equivalent of NATO worked?

asian treaty organisation +ATO
given the fact that we now know this will never occur purely due to the fact that indo-US relations have reached new heights and india doesn't see US as a threat anymore

FullTank · 04-26-2008, 22:10 PM

Our biggest enemy is China.

Moreover chinas closest ally is pakistan.

Who do we have to fight by aligning with China?What is India's gain?

And say that war is successful and then China and Pak turn against India who do we align with now?

An enemy close by is more dangerous than an enemy far away.Oh hell cant help it if people want to live in fantasy land?

If this did happen it would mean india has been taken over by commies supported by spineless. Currently its spineless supported by commies...that is fine.

1947 · 04-26-2008, 22:30 PM

what i wanted to know was would it have worked given our past and our differences?

**Officer of Engineers** · 04-27-2008, 00:38 AM

They can put together some real nice dog-&-pony shows but I sincerely doubt a Russian General would be commanding a Chinese group army anytime soon. And given the type of joint exercises done by the Indian and Chinese armies, I rather watch a Bruce Lee-Chuck Norris fight.

Tronic · 04-27-2008, 01:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1947

what i wanted to know was would it have worked given our past and our differences?

No.

1947 · 04-27-2008, 03:46 AM

this question is in regards to a time after the fall or the soviet union and before america offered india the nuclear deal

zraver · 04-27-2008, 04:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1947

this question is in regards to a time after the fall or the soviet union and before america offered india the nuclear deal

It does not matter what time, India and China are enemies and probaly always will be. India was nothing but a foil for the Soviets verses China the same way Pakistan is a foil for China vs India.

Skywatcher · 04-27-2008, 13:35 PM

This would have to require something unimaginably stupid from an American administration which would at least have to involve alien space bats.

Of course, if said admin got into power (I am speaking hypothetically, I don't have any candidate or person in mind) a Moscow Beijing New Delhi axis would be the least of everyone's worries.

dark-alias · 04-27-2008, 15:28 PM

Poor taiwan

Sumku · 04-27-2008, 17:05 PM

This is not workable. Irrespective of how hard India and China try to forget their differences, the differences would still be there.

You cant expect India to forget as to who gave Nuke's to Pakistan in the First place.

Again if we forget that who gave Nuke's to Pakistan, then first China has to Vacate Askai Chin, accept Sikkim and Arunanchal Pradesh to be an integral part of India, Give up Gwadar seaport that its developing in Pakistan, literally break KKH[Karakoram Highway], Free Tibet and accept that it gave Pakistan the Nukes and that it was a mistake, cutoff of military supplies to Pakistan, Accept that entire J&K is a part of India[even that which is under occupation of Pak].

Its Just not possible.I personally dont see it happening for next 100 years.

India+Russia+Taiwan[Lets say for the moment] is quite possible.

**Officer of Engineers** · 04-27-2008, 17:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sumku

India+Russia+Taiwan[Lets say for the moment] is quite possible.

No, it's not.

Sumku · 04-27-2008, 17:31 PM

I know

But if you are projecting for 100 years than may be it will
But even after 1000 years, India+Russia+China is not happenning

dave lukins · 04-27-2008, 19:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dark-alias

Poor taiwan

Taiwan is sleeping... the sign says "Do not Disturb"

Tronic · 04-28-2008, 01:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sumku

I know

But if you are projecting for 100 years than may be it will
But even after 1000 years, India+Russia+China is not happenning

I disagree with both statements. Japan and US relationship proves the second wrong.

Tronic · 04-28-2008, 01:37 AM

By the way, they already have an asian "ATO", its called SCO; Just look at how well that is working out.

04-26-2008, 21:29 PM	#1 (permalink)
1947 Regular Join Date: 04-15-08 Location: Melbourne Posts: 148 Country:	ATO=a russian+chinese+indian NATO would a Russian, Chinese and Indian organization equivalent of NATO worked? asian treaty organisation +ATO given the fact that we now know this will never occur purely due to the fact that indo-US relations have reached new heights and india doesn't see US as a threat anymore

04-26-2008, 22:10 PM	#2 (permalink)
FullTank Patron Join Date: 07-11-07 Location: West Des Moines, Iowa Posts: 259	Our biggest enemy is China. Moreover chinas closest ally is pakistan. Who do we have to fight by aligning with China?What is India's gain? And say that war is successful and then China and Pak turn against India who do we align with now? An enemy close by is more dangerous than an enemy far away.Oh hell cant help it if people want to live in fantasy land? If this did happen it would mean india has been taken over by commies supported by spineless. Currently its spineless supported by commies...that is fine. __________________ God is a cruise missile.

04-27-2008, 00:38 AM	#4 (permalink)
Officer of Engineers Moderator Scotch taster Join Date: 08-06-03 Posts: 14,876 Country:	They can put together some real nice dog-&-pony shows but I sincerely doubt a Russian General would be commanding a Chinese group army anytime soon. And given the type of joint exercises done by the Indian and Chinese armies, I rather watch a Bruce Lee-Chuck Norris fight. __________________ Chimo

04-27-2008, 17:05 PM	#10 (permalink)
Sumku Regular Join Date: 04-12-08 Location: Allahabad Posts: 94 Country:	This is not workable. Irrespective of how hard India and China try to forget their differences, the differences would still be there. You cant expect India to forget as to who gave Nuke's to Pakistan in the First place. Again if we forget that who gave Nuke's to Pakistan, then first China has to Vacate Askai Chin, accept Sikkim and Arunanchal Pradesh to be an integral part of India, Give up Gwadar seaport that its developing in Pakistan, literally break KKH[Karakoram Highway], Free Tibet and accept that it gave Pakistan the Nukes and that it was a mistake, cutoff of military supplies to Pakistan, Accept that entire J&K is a part of India[even that which is under occupation of Pak]. Its Just not possible.I personally dont see it happening for next 100 years. India+Russia+Taiwan[Lets say for the moment] is quite possible. __________________ Sumit Kumar

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

04-26-2008, 22:30 PM	#3 (permalink)
1947 Regular Join Date: 04-15-08 Location: Melbourne Posts: 148 Country:	what i wanted to know was would it have worked given our past and our differences?

04-27-2008, 03:46 AM	#6 (permalink)
1947 Regular Join Date: 04-15-08 Location: Melbourne Posts: 148 Country:	this question is in regards to a time after the fall or the soviet union and before america offered india the nuclear deal

04-27-2008, 13:35 PM	#8 (permalink)
Skywatcher Regular Join Date: 03-14-08 Posts: 41	This would have to require something unimaginably stupid from an American administration which would at least have to involve alien space bats. Of course, if said admin got into power (I am speaking hypothetically, I don't have any candidate or person in mind) a Moscow Beijing New Delhi axis would be the least of everyone's worries.

04-27-2008, 15:28 PM	#9 (permalink)
dark-alias *Military Professional* Join Date: 03-28-08 Location: California Posts: 218 Country:	Poor taiwan

04-27-2008, 17:31 PM	#12 (permalink)
Sumku Regular Join Date: 04-12-08 Location: Allahabad Posts: 94 Country:	I know But if you are projecting for 100 years than may be it will But even after 1000 years, India+Russia+China is not happenning

04-28-2008, 01:37 AM	#15 (permalink)
Tronic Navajo Code Talker *Senior Contributor* Join Date: 12-27-04 Location: Patiala, India Posts: 5,140 Country:	By the way, they already have an asian "ATO", its called SCO; Just look at how well that is working out.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
India Vs. China (borderline War)	Kontakt Era	Land Forces	452	04-21-2008 19:59 PM
Mig-29 K/kub Fighters For India, First pictures	Endangered	Military Aviation	62	06-10-2007 18:03 PM
How clean is India?	Neo	Political Discussions	163	05-03-2006 19:09 PM
Bangladesh plays the China card	Ray	South Asian Defense Topics	136	10-17-2005 10:14 AM
Analysis: Chechnya	Ironduke	The Western Alliance	1	05-07-2004 10:36 AM