Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Royal Navy Analysis

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Royal Navy Analysis

    I put this together some three weeks ago:

    RN Force Structure, Committments, Operations and Intervention/Contingency Plans

    Much has been written about the UK's Royal Navy draw-down.* In particular dropping from 32 Destroyers/Frigates to 25. This is an attempt to give a brief analysis of its effect on force stucture and operations.

    *http://navy-matters.beedall.com/ed200804.htm


    Force Structure for 2006

    MAJOR UNITS ONLY
    (Full Load Displacement where used is stated thus "1000fl")
    <UK>*
    CARRIERS
    0+2 CVF Queen Elizabeth class(to replace the two below in 2012 and 2015)
    2 CVH Invincible class (Invincible paid-off August 2005, Ark Royal is in a major refit until end of 2006)
    DESTROYERS
    0+8 Type 45 class 7400fl SAMPSON/Sylver VLS/ASTER (to replace the Type 42)
    8 Type 42 class 4300-4800fl Sea Dart (to decommission from 2009-2013)
    FRIGATES
    4 Type 22 4900fl
    13 Type 23 4300fl
    SUBMARINES
    0+6 SSN Astute class(to replace some of those below)
    9 SSN Trafalger/Swiftsure class (to drawdown to eight by 2008 )
    4 SSBN Vanguard class
    AMPHIBIOUS
    1 LPH Ocean class
    1 AGH Argus class
    2 LPD Albion class
    4 LSD Largs Bay class
    MINE WARFARE
    8 MHC Sandown class
    8 MCM Hunt class
    Replenishment
    2 AO Wave class
    1 AO Oakleaf class (Will retire 2010)
    3 AO Leaf class (Will retire 2009-2010)
    2 AO Rover class (Will retire 2009-2010)
    2 AOR Victoria class
    2 AE Fort Grange
    1 ARS Diligence(not a replenishment ship but its only major repair and salvage unit)

    *Entry for RN from a World Navies Listing compiled by this author (complete list available on request)

    Committments, Standing Tasks & Enduring Ops

    2004
    1. SNMG-1 (was STANAVFORLANT the NATO Squadron-Atlantic(Withdrawn))
    2. SNMG-2 (was STANNAVFORMED the NATO Squadron- Mediterranean)
    3. Fleet Ready Escort- FRE (UK Patrol)
    4. Atlantic Patrol Task- North
    5. Pacific Patrol Task- South
    6. Arabian Gulf
    7. Indian Ocean/ Far East

    Th UK is reducing from seven full-time committments/operations in 2004 involving one Destroyer/Frigate each to fewer in number. With some of those tasks realigned. The RN has withdrawn from the NATO squadron Atlantic The Arabian Gulf & IO/FE comittment is to be combined into one ship or so it appears. APT-N is to be reduced from July-October of each year. The NATO Squadron MED, APT-S and the FRE ship tasks will remain unchanged for now. The MED may also at some point be reduced from a year-round task.

    Intervention/Contingency Plans

    In addition the RN will provide units for three simultaneous contingency taskings* or one Medium Scale Intervention. Carrier and Amphibious Task Groups are formed as neccessary around the operational carrier and LPH Ocean.

    The below three scenarios were made in July 2004 as to the number of Destroyers/Frigates needed to support the underlying assumptions . Three or four D/F's are normally necessary to support each enduring op & standing committment. With deployment reductions this may be somewhat relaxed. Example- The APT-N ship is only on station 3-4 months a year rather than a unit deployed year-round. :

    #1
    2 Two Enduring Medium Scale Operations
    2 Two Enduring Small Scale Operations
    2 Two Small Scale Intervention
    1 One Standing Committment
    9 **Factors
    16 Total Destroyers/Frigates

    #2
    2 Two Enduring Medium Scale Operations
    2 Two Enduring Small Scale Operations
    1 Standing Committment
    9 Medium Scale Intervention
    11 **Factors
    25 Total Destroyers/Frigates(As many as eight of these will be in "Reduced Support Status".)*

    #3
    12 One Large Scale Operation
    1 Standing Committment
    4 **Factors
    17 Total Destroyers/Frigates

    It appears that a modified scenario #2 has been decided on:

    #2
    2 Enduring medium scale op(Gulf/IO/FE & APT-S)
    2 Enduring small scale op(APT-N & MED)
    1 Standing committment(FRE)
    9 Medium scale intervention
    11 **Factors(including ships in refit, post-deployed, training and pre-depoyment work-up)
    25 Total

    A large scale operation would most likely take many years for the RN to recover from as regards operational tempo.

    *Which would be quite similar to scenario #1 seeing as how as many as eight D/F are usually in RSS. Whether, in this authors opinion, that is an official or unofficial practice is a moot point.

    RSS definition:
    "Under the revised arrangements, all ships have been given either normal support status or reduced support status. Ships with reduced support status will, generally, only receive support for defects affecting health and safety and environmental safety. The intention is to preserve a core capability to deploy a medium scale task group for the Joint Rapid Reaction Force and to ensure that priority peacetime tasks remain supported and that non-essential activity is removed from the Royal Navy’s programme. "

    http://www.nao.org.uk/publications/n...-06/050672.pdf


    **The factors include the number of units required in the force structure to allow generation of the deployed force and the units held to rotate the enduring operations.

    RFA-Replenishment Ships

    More should be said about these ships as World-Wide Ops/Interventions are unsustainable without them.

    The oilers of the Rover and Leaf classes are to be replaced by the new MARS* program and the Sir class LST's by the four new Largs Bay class LPD/LSD. Argus can also be used to augment amphibious forces.

    Designation/Name/ In-service Date/Forecast Decommissioning Date

    Aviation Training and Primary Casualty Reception Ship
    AGH Argus 1988 2020

    Repair Ship
    ARS Diligence 1984 2014

    Oilers
    AO- Grey Rover 1970 2006
    AO- Gold Rover 1974 2009
    AO- Black Rover 1974 2010
    AO- Oakleaf 1986 2010
    AO- Brambleleaf 1980 2009
    AO- Orangeleaf 1984 2009
    AO- Bayleaf 1982 2010
    AO- Wave Knight 2003 2028
    AO- Wave Ruler 2003 2028

    Ammunition, Food and Stores Ships
    AE- Fort Rosalie 1978 2013
    AE- Fort Austin 1979 2014

    Replenishment Oilers
    AOR Fort George 1994 2019
    AOR Fort Victoria 1994 2019

    Landing Ship Tank
    LST Sir Bedivere 1967 2011
    LST Sir Tristram 1967 2006
    LST Sir Galahad 1987 2006

    *Military Afloat Reach and Sustainability (MARS)

    Decommissioning dates for Destroyers/Frigates

    Ship/ Planned decommissioning date

    Type 42 Batch 2 destroyers:

    HMS Exeter 2009
    HMS Southampton 2010
    HMS Nottingham 2012
    HMS Liverpool 2009

    Type 42 Batch 3 destroyers:
    HMS Manchester 2011
    HMS Gloucester 2011
    HMS Edinburgh 2013
    HMS York 2012

    Type 22 frigates:

    HMS Cornwall 2015
    HMS Cumberland 2017
    HMS Campbeltown 2017
    HMS Chatham 2018

    Type 23 frigates:

    HMS Argyll 2019
    HMS Lancaster 2019
    HMS Iron Duke 2020
    HMS Monmouth 2021
    HMS Montrose 2021
    HMS Westminster 2021
    HMS Northumberland 2022
    HMS Richmond 2022
    HMS Somerset 2023
    HMS Sutherland 2025
    HMS Kent 2028
    HMS Portland 2028
    HMS St. Albans 2029

    Decommissioning Dates for Submarines:
    Mr. Ingram [holding answer 20 July 2005]: No decisions have been taken on the out of service dates (OSDs) for the Royal Navy's Vanguard class SSBNs, nor about any potential replacement. The current planned OSDs for the Swiftsure and Trafalgar class SSNs are detailed as follows:

    Swiftsure class SSNs:

    2008 HMS Superb
    2010 HMS Sceptre

    Trafalgar class SSNs:

    2008 HMS Trafalgar
    2011 HMS Turbulent
    2013 HMS Tireless
    2015 HMS Torbay
    2017 HMS Trenchant
    2019 HMS Talent
    2022 HMS Triumph

    The new Astute class SSNs will progressively supersede the current capability. The first of class is planned to enter service in 2009.

    Current duties:

    13 Jul 2005

    Maritime Forces
    Dr. Julian Lewis: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the (a) Royal Navy and (b) Royal Fleet Auxiliary vessels which have been given the reduced support status referred to in paragraph 2.9 of the National Audit Office report on military readiness. [9695]

    Mr. Ingram [holding answer 7 July 2005]: The process of designating ships to receive the reduced level of support referred to by the National Audit Office enables the Royal Navy to maintain its ability to mount a medium scale operation at short notice and maximise its ability to undertake priority peacetime tasks. The Royal Navy ships placed on reduced support status are as follows:

    HMS Invincible CVH-decom
    HMS Ark Royal CVH-refit
    HMS Albion LPD
    HMS Cardiff-decom
    HMS Exeter
    HMS Liverpool
    HMS Cumberland
    HMS Grafton(Training-Summer leave-in September will be undergoing a period of planned maintenance before sailing once again in support of trainee navigating officers.)
    HMS Marlborough-decom
    HMS Monmouth
    HMS Richmond
    HMS St. Albans
    HMS Sutherland
    HMS Atherstone-MCM
    HMS Brecon MCM-decom
    HMS Cottesmore MCM-decom
    HMS Dulverton MCM-decom
    HMS Middleton-MCM
    HMS Pembroke-MHC
    HMS Penzance-MHC
    HMS Ramsey-MHC
    HMS Shoreham-MHC
    HMS Walney-MHC
    HMS Leeds Castle OPV-decom
    No RFA ships are on reduced support status.

    Active ships in RSS:

    HMS Exeter
    HMS Liverpool(post-deployed August 4th)
    HMS Cumberland(deployed August 5th)
    HMS Monmouth
    HMS St. Albans
    HMS Sutherland
    HMS Richmond RSS in refit.

    Ships in a low-state of readiness but not RSS:

    Ships in refit:

    HMS Northumberland(now coming out)
    HMS Edinburgh
    HMS Cornwall
    HMS Kent(now coming out)

    Post-deployed:
    HMS Gloucester
    HMS Manchester

    Pre-deployment work-up:
    HMS Southhampton(APTN-S)

    Training:
    Iron Duke

    None of the above 8 ships are listed in RSS or a High-state of readiness.

    That leaves as of July 21:

    UK Maritime Security: HMS Montrose

    Mediterranean (Nato's Standing NRF Maritime Group 2): HMS Somerset(post-deployed August 3rd)(Relief?)

    Atlantic Patrol Task (South): HMS Portland(Southhampton to relieve early September)

    Gulf: HMS Argyll( Relief Campbelltown in Suez August 3 approx)

    Atlantic Patrol Task (North): HMS Liverpool(RSS)(post-deployed August 4th)(Cumberland deployed August 5th)

    Arabian Sea and Indian Ocean: HMS York (double assigned as JRRF unit)

    Plus

    The following major Royal Navy warships are available to the Joint Rapid Reaction Force at High or Very High Readiness for contingent operations:

    HMS Illustrious CVH
    HMS Ocean LPD
    HMS Albion-(RSS)
    HMS Bulwark-(soon to be)
    HMS Cumberland- (RSS)(Deployed August 5th)
    HMS Campbeltown- deployed Gulf
    HMS Chatham-post-deployed
    HMS Nottingham-post-deployed
    HMS York(see above)
    HMS Exeter-(RSS)
    HMS Westminster- post-refit Training
    HMS Sutherland-(RSS)
    HMS St. Albans-(RSS)
    HMS Monmouth-(RSS)
    HMS Lancaster-Training

    Where a destroyer/frigate duties are not mentioned assume for the most part minor upkeep and training are being done.

    Many ships are enjoying Summer Leave at this time.

    References:

    Force Structure:

    various but in particular Combat Fleets 2005-2006 and www.royalnavy.mod.uk

    Committments, Operations and Intervention/Contingency Plans:

    March 2005 House of Commons Report

    http://www.parliament.the-stationery...ce/45/4507.htm


    July 2004 White Paper

    http://www.mod.uk/linked_files/issue...269/cm6269.pdf

    July 2005 White Paper

    http://www.mod.uk/linked_files/issue...ity/cm6616.pdf

    Decommissioning dates and other info:

    Hansard http://www.parliament.uk/index.cfm

  • #2
    Rick,
    HMS Invincible was paid off last month?? Insanity!

    And Ark Royal is in refit...leaving only Illustrious.
    Is this Labour's idea of a sick joke, or are other forces at work here?
    “He was the most prodigious personification of all human inferiorities. He was an utterly incapable, unadapted, irresponsible, psychopathic personality, full of empty, infantile fantasies, but cursed with the keen intuition of a rat or a guttersnipe. He represented the shadow, the inferior part of everybody’s personality, in an overwhelming degree, and this was another reason why they fell for him.”

    Comment


    • #3
      Mnay factors are involved.

      The RN has two expensive shipbuilding projects underway:

      Astute class SSN's

      Type 45 DDG's

      In addition the RN is just completing the revitalization of its Amphibious fleet with:

      LPH Ocean 1999
      LPD Albion 2003
      LPD Bulwark 2004
      LSD Largs Bay class 2005-2006

      And have the CVF carrier replacement program fast coming up along with the MARS program for replacement of the vast majority of its logistic fleet.

      None of the above fleet recapitaliztion has been or will be cheap. Ergo cuts must be made somewhere.

      In addition the Sea Harriers are almost all gone. Leaving only RAF ground attack Harriers for use on the Invincibles.

      Comment


      • #4
        Guess I've been living in la-la land or something....

        What the heck are the RN carrier's deploying with? Mostly RAF Harriers?

        They are being awfully optimistic about the replacement carrier timetable.
        Have they even been laid down yet?

        I'd say they need them more than the SSN replacements.

        Ah well, I don't make MOD policy....for some strange reason
        “He was the most prodigious personification of all human inferiorities. He was an utterly incapable, unadapted, irresponsible, psychopathic personality, full of empty, infantile fantasies, but cursed with the keen intuition of a rat or a guttersnipe. He represented the shadow, the inferior part of everybody’s personality, in an overwhelming degree, and this was another reason why they fell for him.”

        Comment


        • #5
          So many questions!!!!!!

          So few answers.

          LOL

          Yes only RAF aircraft soon.

          No they havent been laid down yet.

          As for SSN's . They are very expensive. They may get 8 but IMHO only 6.


          The USN is the same maybe even moreso.

          But then what do you want to do?

          Send the boys out with the best or something less??????????

          The paradigm has changed.

          If a "real" war erupts it will be quick and brutal. It will be won or lost in a matter of hours.

          Not even days,weeks or months. Much less years.

          And yet you have to balance that with forces to operate in times of less urgency.

          Its tough. Im glad I dont have to make these types of decisions. Are not you ?
          Last edited by rickusn; 05 Sep 05,, 05:01.

          Comment


          • #6
            It's pathetic in a minute we are only going to have a defence force or not even that.

            Comment


            • #7
              Thanks for the effort and info Rickusn.

              Jonathan

              Comment


              • #8
                a nice coastal force
                Can the last person to leave the UK please turn out the lights
                cheers Jeff

                Comment

                Working...
                X