PDA

View Full Version : Was Gen. Scott's Assement of Lee Accurate?



JAD_333
03 Dec 11,, 08:22
Lee had served on Scott's staff during the war with Mexico. Scott was impressed with what he saw.

He said Lee "was the very best soldier I ever saw in the field." Another officer wrote, "Scott had an almost idolatrous fancy for Lee, whose military genius he estimated far above that of any other officer of the army." Scott suggested that in the event of war, the government should insure Lee's life for $5 million a year." (Emory A. Thomas, Robert E Lee: A Biography; New York, 1995)

Do you agree or disagree with his assessment?

Shek
04 Dec 11,, 01:22
:)

http://www.worldaffairsboard.com/american-civil-war/53928-what-if-lee-had-accepted-command-federal-forces.html

JAD_333
04 Dec 11,, 03:13
Damn, and I looked to see if a thread had ever been started with that topic.

So, I'll change this one to an assessment of Scott's opinion of Lee.

Thanks for not making my day.:)