Quote:
Originally Posted by Adux
How can a Islamic state provide equality to its citizens, the very word 'Islamic State' stomps on the minorities, that they dont have much say in the country. As long as non-muslim cant have all the freedoms of that a muslim enjoys , even the right to be elected to the highest office as well as not having to pay something as the zakat. How can there equality, forget secularism, lets not beat around the bush about what an Islamic state is ,An Islamic state catagorically states non-muslims will always remain second class citizens by the doors it has closed for non-muslims. Its just another form of racisim in my opinion.
|
Lets get something clear - I am not arguing that the majority of the Islamic States that exist today are bastions of freedom and equality, I am not arguing that they do not have any repressive or discriminatory laws. I am arguing that being an Islamic State does not preclude these nations from evolving and reforming. I am arguing that the nature of these States does not imply anything about the "widespread tolerance", or lack of, of their citizens.
You base your argument on the most vitriolic, extreme and intolerant interpretations of Islam that exist - I base my argument on the moderate, respectful and tolerant strain of Islam that I know, that I grew up with - that I believe a majority of Muslims share.
I don't believe non-Muslims and women are second class citizens, that they cannot have equal rights - you seem to be insisting that I do - Takiyah and all eh..
Will it be perfect, probably not - In Pakistan for example I do not see the restrictions on the President and Prime Minister going away any time soon. But as long as we can work towards non-Muslims, and Muslims, being able to exercise all other rights and have all freedoms, I'll be happy.