View Single Post
Old 03-27-2008, 18:54 PM   #123 (permalink)
Agnostic Muslim
Contributor
 
Agnostic Muslim's Avatar
 
Join Date: 12-12-07
Location: Auburn Hills
Posts: 461
Country:
Chanakya Reply:

Quote:
Also if you wish for such a close association between the state and religion why do you not realize that the acts of the state then reflect upon the religion. When the Islamic Republic of Pakistan supports forces that maim, kill and terrorize innocents then exactly who are we to blame? Islam or Pakistan?
I disagree with the last statement, and this isn't the thread to get into it, but Western Nations have also sponsored and supported murdering, destructive regimes and personalities in th ename of "national interest". Pakistan did the same - and I would argue that it wasn't so the Taliban could kill people for not growing beards, but so that they could protect Pakistani interests in Afghanistan.

Similarly, support for the Kashmir insurgency was not intended to be directed against innocents (though it could be argued that some religiously extreme ISI officers may not have had any qualms about Hindu civillians being killed), it was done to gain an advantage vs India.

Pakistan's actions/policies gone awry, can be viewed in the same light as those of the US gone awry I would argue - they were flawed, but taken in the desire to further a perceived "just national cause". Its what nations do - it doesn't necessarily reflect upon the beliefs of 1.5 billion Muslims.
__________________
Pakistan is not going to be a theocratic state to be ruled by priests with a divine mission - Jinnah
Agnostic Muslim is offline   Reply With Quote