Quote:
Originally Posted by Rick DeBay
Do you have any specific criticisms of the paper, or are they all ad hominem?
|
I'm saying that he had an answer in mind from the beginning. A long time USNFSA member and battleship reactivation advocate is going to develop a answer that fits his preconceived notions.
Do you really think that he would come to a conclusion that he has been wrong all these years and the Navy's current trend is correct, or some other system is the right path.
Its not something that I accuse only him of doing. We all do it.
If An Air Force B-52 pilot or AF officer on the SDB program was asked to develop the best means of fire support in support of an amphibious operation. The Air Force will play a staring role and it will include B-52s launching JSOWs
as "The best option".
A submariner would have Ohios launching some form of Tom or Navalized GMLRS.
Its the nature of our species. Not some Shawn Welch is a .......