View Single Post
Old 11-29-2006, 00:34 AM   #7 (permalink)
Yirmeyahu
Banished
Regular
 
Join Date: 11-27-06
Posts: 80
Country:
Answers

Stan187,

I observed that the element of racism exists in the phenomenon of considering every Palestinian a "terrorist". Whether you are racist, I know not, but your prejudice, as I observed, is apparent, and I don't reject the possibility.

You asked me whether it was "MORE right to kidnap a soldier than a civilian". This is an invalid question, since I don't believe either is "right". The abduction and killing of Israeli soldiers in this case was wrong. However, it is a far more serious crime to kidnap civilians. This is true just as it is true that it is a crime to kill civilians during war, but is not a crime to kill soldiers.

As for the rest, it's nonsense that warrants no response. I would merely suggest you try to respond what I actually say, rather than trying to construct strawman arguments. It's of little practical use to do so, and it's dishonest. Telling me to "go kill yourself" is also unconstructive, albeit instructive as to your ability or willingness to meaningfully engage in a discussion of the facts.
Yirmeyahu is offline   Reply With Quote