Quote:
Originally Posted by Samudra
Excuse me chaps, I got a problem with you guys if you're going to insist on a blanket ban on reservations.
I'm all for reservations for the SC/ST Communities. Those people will go nowhere without the reservations, scholarships and other facilities. What the government is doing for them at this moment is certainly not adequate. Taking away reservations from them would be a disaster.
Now, coming to the OBC class - I do not think they need reservations. Yet some of castes belonging to OBC sections are in a terrible state even today. Especially in rural areas and states like Orissa. So some kind of criteria has to worked out to decide if the candidate requires a seat/job under reservation.
|
See, I do agree that these folks have to be helped, but giving them jobs over people who are more qualified then them???
Quotas and Reservations do nothing for sociey except put less-qualified people in power!!! That is, if you think with a clear mind, one of the most idiotic decisions that have been made. These people have to be helped but they shouldn't be given jobs and seats even though they are less-skilled. What the government should do rather is to try to increase AID to them to help them get those crucial skills rather then giving them out jobs which could've been handled by more qualified people. If the "seats by caste" theory was used in the army, realize what a disastor that would be.
The solution to the problem is for the government to subsidize the education for low-income families, open up schools for the poor people and other facilities where they can actually grow those skills as required and then be able to compete for the seats like the rest. That is a much better way then handing over the seats because they come from a poor background.
Quote:
Gentlemen, the SC/ST community has done so much for our society. None of us would clean toilets, empty sewage tanks and work 12 hours in the farm generation after generation with less than adequate wages. Oh and dont forget the untouchablitiy factor.
Nothing bad will befall upon this society if the sons and daughters of SC/STs are given an opportunity.It is in these people will India Shine!
So no, dont criticise reservations as a whole. As for reservation for Moslems, I still do not think it will come around. The SC is around.
|
Again, I am not against helping the poor people but reservations are harming others while benefitting some. Just because of some people's handicaps, other people should not be punished; the government should rather work towards building the proper facilities for the poor so they can grow their skills rather then hand them out seats despite other people being more fit then them.