View Single Post
Old 09-09-2005, 08:27 AM   #49 (permalink)
Hongkongfuey
Banished
 
Hongkongfuey's Avatar
 
Join Date: 08-25-05
Posts: 372
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jay
Ok, lets for a moment consider that the people who attended the conference were indeed scholars, lets see what you going to reply about this...
Quote:
In the center of Dacca, the main city of East Pakistan, the army set fire to 25 square blocks and then mowed down those trying to escape.<72> Thousands were massacred in Dacca in the first few days<73> and the killings spread throughout the countryside. Bengali guerrilla resistance led to further bloody reprisals. U.S. consular officials in Dacca reported privately to Washington that "selective genocide" was going on.<74> A World Bank mission reported in July that in every city it visited there were areas razed and in every district there were "villages which have simply ceased to exist."<75> Sober estimates by the summer put the death toll between two and three hundred thousand.<76> ("When one fights, one does not throw flowers," Yahya told the press<77>). Literally millions of Bengalis fled across the border into India in what was probably history's largest one-way movement of refugees in so short a time.<78>
72. _Time_, 3 May 1971, in U.S. Senate, Subcommittee to Investigate Problems with Refugees and Escapees of the Committee on the Judiciary, _Relief Problems in East Pakistan and India_, part 1, 92nd Cong., 1st sess., 28 June 1971; part 2, 92nd Cong., 1st sess., 30 Sept. 1971; part 3, 92nd Cong., 1st sess., 30 Sept. 1971, p. I:105.

73. See news reports reprinted in U.S. Senate, _Relief Problems in East Pakistan and India_, pp. I:104-05.

74. Morris, _Uncertain Greatness_, p. 216.

75. U.S. Senate, _Relief Problems in East Pakistan and India_, p. I:212.

76. _Le Monde_, 10 June 1971; _New York Times_, 14 July 1971 (Sydney H. Schanberg), _Washington Post_, 23 Aug. 1971 (Stephen Klaidman), reprinted in U.S. Senate, _Relief Problems in East Pakistan and India_, pp. I:180, 163, II:342.

77. Interview with _Le Figaro_ reported in _New York Times_, 29 Sept. 1971, quoted in U Thant, _View from the U.N._, Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1978, p. 426.

78. John P. Lewis testimony in U.S. Senate, _Relief Problems in East Pakistan and India_, p. II:242.

http://www.zmag.org/zmag/articles/ShalomHumnCri.html


Now, as you see these are testimonials given in US Congress. I will consider these as authentic than Sarmila Bose's research that was done a long time after the genocide itself took place.
"Were indeed scholars"?? lol
  • Dr. Peter A. Kraemer, Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State
  • Dr. Ali Riaz, Illinois State University
  • Ambassador R. Nicholas Burns, Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs
  • Dr. Gary R. Hess, Bowling Green State University
  • Dr. Sumit Ganguly, Indiana University
  • Dr. Robert J. McMahon, The Ohio State University
  • Dr. Imtiaz Ahmed, University of Dhaka
  • Dr. Sarmila Bose, George Washington University
  • F.S. Aijazuddin, OBE

Just a few who took part in the discussions on the 1971 war. They look pretty important to me, not like the quacks you keep quoting. All you do is quote journalists many of whom arent independent, they have vested interests. Why dont you get it through your heads, they have not done a head count, they are guessing, they cannot distinguish between Biharis and Bengalis and it was the Bengalis that slaughtered the Biharis not the Pakistan Army. I dont deny there were killing of innocents - it's a guerilla war and that is the nature of such. I also believe there might well have been an initial crackdown phase during which time atrocities were possibly committed like on the night of the 25th at Dhaka University. But some of your quotes say thousands were mown down in the first few days (ref 73). Apparently reference 73 are news reports!! You call news reports evidence????? They could have been written by a Bengali, even a member of Mukti Bahini!!!! Do you not know about impartiality?

Last edited by Hongkongfuey : 09-09-2005 at 08:29 AM.
Hongkongfuey is offline   Reply With Quote